1.
“Once a guy requested a custom video of another woman and me covering each other in baby oil while wearing fake long nails, spanking and tickling each other, and kind of presenting each other’s butts to the camera. It was pretty standard, except that he wanted us to use the words ‘tushie’ and ‘hiney’ instead of ‘butt’ or ‘ass.’ No cussing was allowed. He also wanted to hear us say the phrase, ‘Look at that shiny hiney’ as many times as we could manage. It was so hard to get through because it was just so specific and silly that it was difficult not to laugh. He was very happy with the video, which is nice, but then he said he was so surprised we had never done ‘shiny hiney’ content before…”
2.
“I was selling old underwear because I was just going to throw them away, but then I decided maybe I could profit from them. Some of the guys asked for my urine and bloody tampons. I did one bloody tampon, but I felt so weird about it after. I have no idea what he even wanted to do with it. I can’t wrap my head around it.”
3.
“I was paid $2,000 for a 30-minute video chat. I dressed like the guy’s mom and told him I was proud of him while he told me about the small accomplishments of his week (one of them being successfully making an omelet).”
4.
“My sister-in-law had a guy ask her to poop in a jar and send it to him. He offered good money for it, but she denied.”
5.
“A guy wanted me to act like I was being blown up like a blueberry, like Violet from Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory. I discovered what inflation fetishes were from them. We discussed the details, and I ran to the store to prep the supplies for the custom (Hubba Bubba lmao). Then he found out I was transgender (even though it’s plastered on my sites and socials), and said he wasn’t interested anymore.”
6.
“My strangest experience so far was when a guy asked me to wear my little sister’s underwear (I don’t have a little sister). There are so many levels of wrong in that, but yeah. He even wanted to tip heavily, like $1,500 or something. But I declined.”
7.
“Some guy tipped me $300 and said, ‘Now you have to take a selfie of yourself stuffing your toothbrush in your [redacted].’ He was so pissed off when I rejected it. I never agreed to anything, nor did I ask for tips before he tipped. Apparently, that happens often (I started OnlyFans recently), and guys think that you owe them something because they tip randomly.”
8.
“I have a guy that visits my inbox every 60 days or so, and pays me a vast sum of money. He sends me a very nice bikini and wants videos of me in the bathtub, submerged, and holding my breath. He has extremely specific requests about when bubbles should escape, how many, and how long I should hold my breath. He never asks anything personal or anything sexual, just the bathtub. It’s not even simulated drowning, it’s just really specific breath play.”
9.
“A guy asked me to send voice notes pretending I was their GPS, saying things like, ‘At the roundabout, take the second exit.'”
10.
“One of the girls I work with has made several naked videos for a younger man. She helps him be more confident with doing things around the house or for his girlfriend in terms of how to cook certain meals, how to sew and knit, things to buy for the house for cleaning or general niceties, understanding periods, how to help his girlfriend out, feminine products, and what he should keep at his place, and general questions about women. She has been his private tutor on life.”
11.
“I’m not an OnlyFans creator, but, for a while, I was a casual partner of a creator. We had sex many times, faceless. A couple of her subscribers asked us if we could come to their wedding after-party and have sex in front of everyone during the night for a genuinely good amount of money. It was not a sex party; they just wanted us as background decor. So people at the party were able to watch us and give instructions.”
12.
“I used to be on OnlyFans. I would never do it again — it’s just not for me. But the strangest request I got was to share pregnancy photos. How they knew I was a mom, I don’t know, because I didn’t post my child for safety reasons.”
13.
“I didn’t work in the industry, but my boss had an OnlyFans account she did part-time. She had a guy who used to pay her $1,000 once a year for a custom request. He sent her a road safety questionnaire to fill in, asking her about how safe she was on the roads, like the green cross code, and wearing seatbelts properly. He then wanted her to film a video of her getting into a car and putting on a seatbelt, not nude or scantily clad. The request even said she could wear what she liked for the video.”
14.
“I was offered $500 by a guy to wear and use a diaper for 24 hours and then send it to him so he could eat it. I declined. I’ve also been paid $200 multiple times to send short videos of me just repeating specific phrases, like calling him a ‘good boy.’ It’s not weird, but for that much money, I would be willing to say a lot more than just praise him.”
15.
“I knew someone who got offered $100 to watch her shave her legs in a bikini ($50 per leg). They were specific about the shaving cream and razor, and sent extra money to get the ones they specified. I get it — I’m fascinated with the how-to videos on men shaving with a straight razor. I’m unsure if I’d ever pay for it.”
16.
“I had someone ask me to meet him in person and kick him in the testicles for an hour straight. He wasn’t willing to offer more than $100 for the hour, so I declined. The risk of meeting someone in person whom I met through the internet wasn’t worth $100.”
17.
“I had a request to stomp on fake fire trucks and cars, and I had to loudly scream, ‘F*ck you, Tiffany! F*ck you, Stephanie!’ over and over. I did it too. It was an easy $500.”
18.
“I have a friend who goes to a guy’s house once a week for about 10 minutes, sits fully clothed across from him, he masturbates, she leaves, and her rent is paid. It’s not a weird request, but also like what?! You’ve got enough disposable income that you can just pay someone’s rent for ultimately about 40 minutes to an hour of their time once a month? That’s wild.”
19.
“I was asked to do a video, but to direct it like David Lynch. Like, masturbate, David-Lynch style.”
20.
“I’m not a creator, but I know a few. One girl I knew started an OF with mostly slightly racy cosplay and lingerie shoots. About a year into it, she got a request from a guy to play League with him. I don’t remember how much he paid, but I think it was a couple of hundred. She did. She even played with him a few more times for free. And then he started sending weird shit, and she had to block him.”
21.
“A guy paid me just to hear me breathe for 20 minutes. It was the easiest $50 I’ve made in my life.”
22.
“She asked for a small jar of my semen. It took me five days to fill up half of it. When she received it, she shared a photo spreading it on bread. It weirded me out, but it was good money.”
23.
“There have been multiple guys who wanted videos of my wife pooping, and we always politely decline. I just find it strange that it’s a common enough thing that we’ve had multiple requests for it.”
24.
“A girl I dated for a short time had an OnlyFans account. She had a guy ask her to send videos of her farting while spreading her butt cheeks. The dude was willing to pay quite a bit of money, but she couldn’t go through with it.”
25.
“Someone asked me to be a vampire, and actually wanted me to bite someone and drink their blood. They offered me $20,000 to do this, but I couldn’t.”
26.
And, “I had a friend who had a pretty successful OnlyFans account during COVID. I used to drive up to cut his hair for him (he worked on movie sets and was still working at the time). And while I was there cutting his hair, he told me he had a guy request to have his wife fly out, have my friend rail his wife, and record it for him. He wanted my friend to ejaculate into a sealed container and for his wife to bring it back. The guy wanted to drink it. My friend was offered $10,000 for it, but didn’t do it. It’s quite the story.”
Note: Some submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.
